6
The Citroen C4 Cactus has downgraded its airbumps, but gained new suspension and engine. Can that turn it into a true rival to the VW Golf and Peugeot 308?

What is it?

When the Citroen C4 Cactus launched in 2014, it was the start of a new style-led era for the French car maker which marked a return to its trademark quirkiness of old.

The car’s Marmite-effect side airbumps, which have since made their way across much of the range, became synonymous with a new time for Citroen under the tenure of Brit boss Linda Jackson. While the styling was divisive, the model was a modest success for Citroen, outselling its more sensible sibling, the C4, in Europe.

This revised model, almost four years later, brings a couple of notable changes. Firstly, those airbumps are resigned to the side sills, a result of customer feedback says Citroen, but still a disappointing step away from its previous characterful design which set it apart from so many rivals.

Secondly there’s its Advanced Comfort programme, which includes a host of technologies intended to “emphasise a feeling of reassurance, comfort and calm,” according to Citroen. Most notably, that means it has Advanced Comfort seats with adjustable lumbar support and an extra layer of foam plus its Progressive Hydraulic Cushions suspension set-up which promises “a magic carpet effect”.

The suspension adds a pair of secondary hydraulic dampers into each coil-sprung suspension corner, replacing the traditional rubber bumpstops at the top and bottom of the wheel travel. Because the damper progressively cushions the wheel travel at the two extremes of movement, engineers have specified more comfort-oriented springs and dampers for the main job of isolating the car body from the road.

The car also gets a revised front end with extra chrome and a prominent Citroën double-chevron badge designed to look more upmarket.

The C4 Cactus has always been a tricky car to position against rivals. Despite Citroen’s earlier insistence that the Cactus’ sibling, the C4, had a place alongside it, it has now confirmed that the C4 Cactus will replace the ageing C4, at least in the mid-term, with a new C4 likely due in 2020. So, for now, traditional hatchbacks such as a Peugeot 308 or Volkswagen Golf are its most obvious rivals, though given its very slightly elevated ride height, there’s crossover (see what I did there) with compact SUVs, too.

We’re driving the three-cylinder 1.2-litre 128bhp unit, the Puretech 130, with six-speed manual, which is already used in many PSA Group cars including the C3 Aircross and Peugeot 308, but only makes its debut on the C4 Cactus now. There are two more engine choices: the lesser-powered 108bhp Puretech 110 is likely to be the biggest seller in the UK, and there’s also a 98bhp BlueHDi 100 diesel.

What's it like?

The most notable change are the Progressive Hydraulic Cushions, intended to absorb and dissipate energy from bumps so there’s no rebound. In truth, that claim is a stretch – in bad, speed-bump-ridden urban situations, there was still plenty of impact, particularly on the rear axle. But, broadly speaking, this revised Cactus C4 is definitely more floaty than the last, making it a comfortable, soft ride for the majority of our test road, which harks back to what old Citroens, such as the CX, were known for. It still doesn’t feel damped as effectively as a VW Golf but it does have a character of its own (and one that will appeal to plenty of people) which is commendably rare in the family hatchback class. That swafty sensation also means more body rolls than other hatchbacks around corners.

Another floaty element: the steering. Citroens aren’t known for their direct, accurate steering, and this one’s no different. The C4 Cactus has vague though pleasantly light steering, but does need plenty of input on anything other than dead straight road, something you don’t find in a Golf and, to a lesser extent, in a Peugeot 308.

Tallied with glitchy gear changes, particularly lower down the range, it’s not awfully intuitive for tricky urban driving, but higher up the gears, there’s a pleasant sweep from fourth to fifth to sixth.

Performance is more than sufficient with this new 128bhp addition to the range, which achieves 0-62mph in 8.7sec. There was less torque from go than expected for a punchy 128bhp three-cylinder, but it held its own on a varied route and was never left wanting. That said, we also tried the 108bhp Puretech 110 and there was little discernable difference between the two - given the latter's almost a grand cheaper, it's worth trying.

Noise from that 128bhp engine and elsewhere was also minimal: another desired effect from Citroen as it attempts to make a person’s time in a Citroen as calm and relaxing as possible under its Advanced Comfort badge.

Where that comfort tag really rings true is the seats. Staying true as it can to the original C4 Cactus bench-like seats, these are big, wide and comfy. On our three-hour drive, there was little fidgeting; the downside is less space in the centre console for storage and very deep seats which affect rear leg room.

The interior is simple: it has a touch of premium on the dashboard, but below that its mostly cheaper plastics. The minimal design is calming and different, though it borders on feeling too sparse, as if there isn’t enough technology befitting of a modern car to play with. That’s because most of it works through the touchscreen…

The PSA Group’s 7.2in touchscreen infotainment system has long been criticised for being glitchy. But it keeps improving and testing the touchscreen today, there was very little delay in reaction. For many, the temperature controls on the screen are a step too far, and indeed, it does seem less natural than more traditional buttons and dials.

We drove the top-of-the-range Flair, one of two trims, which gets the kitchen sink then some. It includes sat nav, rear parking sensors and reversing camera, panoramic glass roof, tinted rear windows plus a host of safety technologies including lane departure warning, blind spot monitoring and reversing camera.

Should I buy one?

Citroen has achieved its goal: to make the updated C4 Cactus more comfortable than its predecessor with better suspension and better seats. It’s ultimately a flawed thing, surpassed in nearly every dimension by one rival or another, but it’s also one of the most characterful cars on the market, despite those dumbed-down air bumps.

The model will never be for the many, but for those who want to stand out from the crowd both in looks and feel behind-the-wheel, it’s a worthy, reasonably priced consideration.

Citroen C4 Cactus Puretech 130 S&S six-speed manual

Price £20,665 Engine three-cylinder, 1999cc, petrol Power 128bhp at 5500rpm Torque 170lb ft at 1750rpm Gearbox six-speed manual Kerb weight 1045kg 0-62mph 8.7sec Top speed 117mph Economy 58.9mpg CO2, tax band 110g/km, 21% Rivals Peugeot 308, VW Golf

 

 

Join the debate

Comments
25

12 February 2018

There will be people who actually like this non-golf thing that arent trying to superficially stand out by buying a car, unlike the superficial importance attached to semi-premium brands. It seems so predictable that every journo would criticise the smaller airbumps.

Mike

12 February 2018

1; airbumps were criticised when they were introduced, and not they're criticised having been hidden a bit. make your mind up. 2; does it feel like a proper citroen? from this article, i can't decide.

13 February 2018

No - sadly no "Citroen" has since the C6 and even more sadly, none is ever likely to.

XXXX just went POP.

12 February 2018

"... and now they're criticised..."

12 February 2018

Stupid Citroen.  Do the rear windows open properly?

So close to being a great car by not following the boring try to be a Golf but never being as 'good' as a Golf route.  As it stands now, better off getting a Golf.

13 February 2018
I came here to ask about the rear windows too. A friend was looking at the previous model and the non-opening window was a deal killer. She bought a Hyundai instead. As she said," If your children start feeling carsick on a windy road, how are you supposed to get them fresh air?"

12 February 2018
Certainly a shame about the air bumps. But the Golf doesn't have them either.

For me the Cactus every time.

But the fact that it isn't a Golf clearly makes Autocar uneasy.

12 February 2018

As the owner of a current Cactus i'd like to have known if the new one, with the emphasis on comfort, has a reach-adjustable steering coloumn..something basic but really get on my t*ts with the current car. Glad to hear it's got better seats and the 130puretech. Shame it looks a whole lot more conventional and expensive.

12 February 2018

I know the original Cactus was an aquired taste but the airbumps were very effective, 3 years of ownership and not one car park ding.

Sadly the new one has lost this distinctive and beneficial feature and I will not be buying the new Cactus as it has the door protection of a conventional car and so I might as well go and get something that is actually a better conventional car.

Possibly people looking for a comfortable conventional car will find the new C4 (ex Cactus) to their liking but there are plenty of comfortably riding cars out there that look better and drive better than the C4 ex Cactus!

Farewell Citroen

12 February 2018

So what was the point of the air bumps? If Citroen caved in to customer feedback, is this about styling? Or was the intended impact absorption in car parks just not worth bothering with?

Whatever it is, this change won't have come cheap, the doors look to entail completely new tooling :-0

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Alpine A110 2018 road test review hero front
    Car review
    25 May 2018
    France’s revered sports car brand is back and chasing some heavyweight scalps
  • Kia Stinger GT S long-term review
    First Drive
    24 May 2018
    This is a 365bhp, rear-drive sports saloon with something to prove. Let’s see if it can
  • Land Rover Discovery
    First Drive
    23 May 2018
    Does the Land Rover Discovery – a vehicle designed to put in the hard yards – cut it as an executive company car? We ran it for seven months to find out
  • Aston Martin Vantage 2018 review hero front
    Car review
    23 May 2018
    Aston Martin’s cheapest model takes a big step up into the 21st century
  • Hyundai i30 N
    Standard spec is good so paint colour is our car’s only option
    First Drive
    22 May 2018
    What’s Hyundai’s first hot hatch and N-brand debutant really like? Let’s find out